Doug Walker
В роли: Nostalgia Critic / Edward Malus

Tamara Chambers
В роли: Tamara

Malcolm Ray
В роли: Audience Member #3 / Malcolm / Sister Honey

Rob Walker
В роли: Audience Member #2 / Beheaded Victim / Carl Copenhagen

Brad Jones
В роли: Cinema Snob

Noah Antwiler
В роли: The Spoony One

James Jarosz
В роли: Audience Member #1 / Quinn

Jim Favia
В роли: Barfly #1

Barney Walker
В роли: Barfly #2

Anthony Sardinha
В роли: Nicolas Cage (голос)