Doug Walker
В роли: Nostalgia Critic / Sad Man / Whitey (голос) / Eleanore (голос) / Grinch Narrator (голос)

Malcolm Ray
В роли: Porn Santa / Audience Member #3 / Davey Stone (голос) / Chris Tucker

Rachel Tietz
В роли: Porn Elf / Audience Member #4 / Benjamin (голос) / Rachel / Eight Crazy Nights fucking with Critic (голос)

James Jarosz
В роли: Audience Member #1

Rob Walker
В роли: Adam Sandler (голос) / Christopher Walken (голос) / Audience Member #2